The Legitimacy and Sunnah Status of Sadl in Prayer

Juristic diversity and the variety of methods used to derive rulings are among the merits of Islamic law, and reflect the breadth and mercy of Islamic law. Yet some who have addressed disputed questions have tended to narrow what the Law has made broad, treating matters of scholarly reasoning as grounds for objection when they should not be, as happened in the question of qabd [folding the hands during prayer] and sadl [leaving the arms at one’s sides during prayer], where each side came to criticise the other. It is in this context that “The Legitimacy and Sunnah Status of Sadl in Prayer” offers a calm, foundational treatment of the issue, from a balanced juristic perspective based on the idea that “qabd is Sunnah, and sadl is Sunnah”. Although the book is devoted to establishing the legitimacy and Sunnah status of sadl on the basis of legal principles and evidence, including the practice of the people of Medina, it neither dismisses nor denies the Sunnah status of qabd. Among its distinguishing features are that it: – applies the jurisprudential principles governing disputed juristic questions; – corrects the notion that the Sunnah is confined to one particular form of practice; – promotes the ethics of juristic disagreement and respect for legal diversity. This work is by no means intended to champion one juristic view over another. Rather, it seeks to guard against partisanship and undue restriction, and to recall the jurisprudence of concord within the breadth and tolerance of Islamic law.